Are Foldable Bike Helmets Less Safe? Study Says Yes

Photo of author
Written by
Published:

Foldable bike helmets — sometimes called collapsible helmets — have surged in popularity with commuters and bike-share riders who want head protection that packs into a bag. But new research from Imperial College London has found that, on average, these helmets guard against serious head injuries less well than conventional designs. The peer-reviewed study, published in the journal Accident Analysis & Prevention and supported by The Road Safety Trust, is the first to directly compare the two helmet types.

The headline figure is stark: collapsible helmets carried an average predicted “linear” injury risk of 24%, compared with 20% for conventional helmets. Here is exactly what the researchers found, why it matters, and how to choose a helmet that actually keeps you safe.

What the Study Found

Imperial’s Dyson School of Design Engineering — through its HEAD Lab — tested 30 commercially available helmets: 24 conventional models and all six collapsible models currently sold in the UK. Each helmet was struck at four impact locations to simulate the most common crashes cyclists experience, and every test was repeated three times with a fresh helmet to account for manufacturing and testing variability.

On linear injury risk — the skull fractures and focal brain injuries caused by the straight-line motion of the head — collapsible helmets averaged 24% versus 20% for conventional models. Four percentage points may sound small, but lead author Dr William Dawber’s team notes that even that gap could translate into a substantial number of additional serious head injuries across a whole population of riders.

Two factors drove the difference. First, weight: collapsible helmets were on average 57% heavier (461g versus 294g), and every extra 10 grams raised linear injury risk by roughly 0.2%. Second, rotational protection: technologies such as MIPS appeared in just one of the six collapsible helmets, compared with 12 of the 24 conventional models. Five of the six collapsible helmets landed in the bottom half of the overall protection rankings.

Notably, the researchers found no difference between the two helmet types in protection against rotational brain injury — the twisting forces that damage the brain’s wiring during an angled impact.

Why It Matters

Head-rotation injuries are serious business: recent studies link them to a higher risk of dementia later in life. And collapsible helmets are exactly the kind of gear people reach for in cities, where shared e-bike and bike-hire schemes such as Santander, Lime and Forest make a packable helmet appealing. If you ride in the UK, it is also worth understanding how Britain’s new e-bike laws are reshaping urban riding.

There is also a price paradox. The collapsible helmets in the study cost £101 on average, versus £64 for conventional ones — riders are often paying more for less protection.

Part of the problem lies in how helmets are certified. Current BSI and CEN safety standards rely on a vertical drop test judged on a pass/fail basis, which measures direct impact but largely ignores the angled, rotational impacts that cause most real-world brain injuries. That gap is why Imperial’s HEAD Lab runs its own Helmet Impact Protection Effectiveness Rating (HIPER) system, which now grades helmets on a diamond-to-bronze medal scale and has been expanded to cover collapsible models.

“Backed by world-class research, [HIPER] is addressing important and timely issues such as foldable helmets, whose growing popularity makes clear, independent evidence about their safety performance for consumers and manufacturers increasingly vital,” said Ruth Purdie OBE, chief executive of The Road Safety Trust.

None of this means foldable helmets are dangerous. As the researchers stress — and as real crashes repeatedly show, including the case where a helmet was credited with saving pro rider Dylan van Baarle’s life — any helmet is far safer than no helmet at all.

Design Isn’t Destiny

The most encouraging finding is that the performance gap is not baked into the folding concept. The team tested two versions of the same collapsible model — one with MIPS rotational protection, one without. The MIPS version ranked second out of all 30 helmets, effectively matching or beating most conventional designs; the version without it ranked 26th. In a separate test, a novel air-inflated collapsible helmet cut linear brain injury risk by 44% compared with the best foam-lined helmet.


In other words, lighter materials and built-in rotational protection can close — or even erase — the gap. Professor Mazdak Ghajari, who founded the HEAD Lab, put it plainly: “Any helmet is safer than no helmet, and innovative designs that appeal to more people are to be applauded.”

What This Means For You

If you ride a shared bike, commute through traffic, or simply want the convenience of a helmet that folds into a bag, you don’t have to abandon collapsible designs — but shop smart:

  • Prioritise rotational protection. Look for MIPS or an equivalent system — it was the single biggest differentiator in the rankings.
  • Mind the weight. Heavier helmets performed worse. A lighter collapsible model lowers linear injury risk.
  • Check independent ratings, not just the CE mark. Every helmet on sale passes the legal minimum; HIPER’s medal ratings reveal how much more protection some offer.
  • Don’t equate price with safety. Imperial’s earlier work found cost is not a reliable guide to protection — and here the pricier collapsible helmets protected less.
  • Replace a helmet after any crash. Foam liners compress once; if you’ve taken an impact, retire the helmet.
  • Fit it properly. Even the best helmet underperforms if it sits loose or tilted back on your head.

The bigger picture for safety-conscious riders is that head protection is one piece of a larger puzzle that also includes visibility, infrastructure and how injuries are tracked — themes we’ve explored in reporting on rising e-bike injuries among children and on the severity of head injuries in e-bike crashes.

Key Takeaways

  • A new Imperial College London study (Accident Analysis & Prevention) found collapsible/foldable bike helmets protect less on average than conventional ones.
  • Average linear injury risk was 24% for collapsible helmets versus 20% for conventional ones; there was no difference in rotational protection.
  • Collapsible helmets were 57% heavier (461g versus 294g) and rarely included MIPS-style rotational technology.
  • The gap isn’t inherent: a MIPS-equipped collapsible helmet ranked second out of 30, and an air-inflated design cut injury risk by 44%.
  • Any helmet beats no helmet — but favour rotational protection, lower weight and strong independent (HIPER) ratings.

Source: Research led by Dr William Dawber at Imperial College London’s Dyson School of Design Engineering, published in Accident Analysis & Prevention and supported by The Road Safety Trust (DOI: 10.1016/j.aap.2026.108814).

Photo of author
With over a decade of experience as a certified personal trainer, two Masters degrees (Exercise Science and Prosthetics and Orthotics), and as a UESCA-certified endurance nutrition and triathlon coach, Amber is as well-qualified as they come when it comes to handling sports science topics for BikeTips. Amber's experience as a triathlon coach demonstrates her broad and deep knowledge of performance cycling.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.